How do they scientifically date the manuscripts?

 

This text is from a transcript of a talk by David Gooding, entitled ‘Christianity on Trial’ (2007).

Download PDF

That is a very interesting question. They have tried carbon-14 dating, for instance, but carbon-14 dating is not accurate enough, in the plus or minus range of possibility, to compete with the method of dating them according to the style of the handwriting.

Now, if you are not an expert in these matters, judging dating by handwriting might seem a very hazardous process but, of course, we have large collections of manuscripts from the ancient world in different languages. We have some in Greek going back to times BC, biblical manuscripts indeed, in Greek, and with them we can compare writing in ordinary secular writing. We can then compare it with writing on monuments. That does, of course, tend to be much more formal. And if you lay out a series of manuscripts side by side, you will see how writing styles change.

You could do it with writing in English. In my father's day, children were taught copperplate handwriting in school, and to my father's last days, he wrote, in his letters and ordinary things, copperplate handwriting—beautiful stuff it was. I cannot attain to that glory, and I notice a lot of my contemporaries don't either. The change in style of English writing is obvious. Given enough manuscripts, you can, therefore, allocate manuscripts, not only to their century, but very often to within ten or twenty years.

That is the most common way that they date the ancient manuscripts. There are other ways of dating when manuscripts are dug up and are found in a certain layer of material that can be dated. They know at least that the manuscript was not younger than the rubbish that was eventually placed on top of it, whatever dating that rubbish might provide.

 
Previous
Previous

Are there no archaeological searches for the body of the Christ?

Next
Next

Do you believe that everyone believes or knows there is a God and some just choose to reject that knowledge?